OFFLINE By Aerie OG Legging

These leggings are trash. The material does not feel like good quality- it is not very soft and not smoothing. Also, they are extremely see through. I heard good things about Aerie leggings, but maybe I bought the wrong ones...

Runs insanely small. I just bought medium sized leggings from Target and figured I'd get some from Aerie too. I have a couple old pairs from Aerie that started to develop holes in the thigh area so I wanted to replace them. I checked my order history from 2 years ago and these are the same exact leggings. Except that they're not. I'm the same size as 2 years ago and could hardly pull these leggings all the way up. I bent over to fix the ankle cuffs and heard a seam snap. The material feels cheap, with no give. I'm 5'3" so I always order short leggings and pants, and my old leggings were also M Short, but these ones are at least 2 inches shorter so even on someone short like me, it's showing ankle. So sad that Aerie decided to cheap out. Returning them all.

Really don’t like the texture of these leggings. They feel poorly made. Also low rise. Not worth the effort of returning but I will not be purchasing again

The reviews and photos seemed so promising, but these were WAY too small on me and way too tight. They hit right at my hips and were cutting off my circulation. I am 5'6" and typically size 8 so I purchased a Medium, which is the size I've ordered for other leggings but this one was just way too small.

These have changed in sizing and length from last year and the year before. I have multiple pairs of S Short and they fit perfectly and were just the right length for a petite, barely 5'3 me. This time I got a M Short as I gained a couple of pounds, these were smaller and much shorter (like a capri or mid calf length). My sister also ordered a pair for herself, XS Short, and she experienced the same sizing issue.

I love the way these leggings look and fit. But after a month they are falling apart. I am very disappointed

The black leggings I ordered have a hole in the side of the leg where the seam simply wasn’t sewn. So disappointed as I already cut the tags off and can’t find my receipt.

I LOVE all things AE. But these are NOT it. They feel cheap and thin like I could've bought them for $2 at walmart. I was running late this morning so I didn't even have time to change out of them so now I'm even more annoyed having to wear them all day

These leggings unfortunately have to go back. I don’t know if I got a faulty pair but I couldn’t get them past my hips and there is no stretch.

The quality of these leggings is terrible. Super see-though and feel way more cotton-y than spandex-y. They fit super loose around the ankles and fall down while you wear them. The other reviews say to size up, which may work for some people but it just lead to my leggings looking baggy around the crotch and falling down while I walked. Bought these leggings on sale and they weren’t even worth $17 much less their regular $24. Don’t waste your money.

I bought a couple of pairs of these to replace previous AE leggings that had rubbed out in the inner thigh area. These are not the same material as the leggings used to be made of, they are tight, not stretchy, and they DO NOT STAY UP. I wore them to work and then to go grocery shopping and I was constantly pulling them back up. Do not recommend.

These leggings feel cheap and are VERY see through. #AEReviewSweepsEntry

The tights do not have much stretch, making them uncomfortable and restrictive. I am a true size small and these were a bit tight. They are mid rise and feel like cheap cotton. Quite uncomfortable to wear.

Not what I thought I had ordered. The material is horrible.

I have been purchasing Aerie leggings for several years now. More recently they have changed to this Offline brand, these leggings are not as soft or stretchy as the Aerie Chill ones they used to sell, they are also a much thinner material. Not a fan of this new material, would not recommend.

To my disappointment Fabric is very scratchy and I will have to return these leggings.

The medium is too small for my hips and thighs but the large is too big in the crotch and knees. Not flattering at all. I’m so disappointed because I have two pairs from aerie that have lasted years but the style is discontinued now. These are not a good replacement.

So upset about how much these suck. I wear size small or medium bought my daughter a large and myself a medium they both fit the same and you can't tell which is which but the feeling of them is nothing like the offline leggings I bought this summer and fall like not even close I spend so much money almost weekly and these leggings are so bad. They feel and fit just like the cotton leggings like no difference so mad AMERICAN EAGLE.

These fit sooo small and there is absolutely no give/stretch. I am always a medium in leggings and could not even get them past my knees!

I typically wear size small leggings both from AE and anywhere else. I wear a 4 in their jeans as well. Something told me to size up and I’m glad I did because these leggings would barely go past my knees at first. I ordered black and red and they arrived with deodorant marks all over them. I managed to get them up and the waist gaps at the back and smashes my butt (and I don’t exactly have a large one). They come up to my ribs in the front but somehow ride low enough in the back for my panties to show and they have no give whatsoever. I suppose paying $8 for leggings was my mistake.

I’ve always heard great things about AE leggings and these had good reviews so I wanted to give them a chance. They are awful; I will never again buy leggings from American Eagle without seeing them in person. Material is extremely cheap and completely see through, they ride down in the waist, little to no stretch, and rough scratchy fabric. I can buy better quality leggings for $10 less at Walmart.....don’t waste your money here.

I got theses after seeing them all over tiktok and people called them lulu quality. If you sweat at all it will show right through the pants. They don’t stay up and it’s definitely not my body that is the problem. And the material is so thin and unflattering

These are not the same leggings we all know and love. In the old leggings, the medium fits great. These are just a teeeensy bit too tight. I noticed that other things I purchased are also tighter than the older clothes in the same size. Pretty disappointing for a company that's supposedly all about body positivity!

I ordered what was then known as their “Chill Feel Comfy” leggings about a year ago and fell in love with them immediately. I still wear that pair today, but felt that my closet needed another, so I bought this pair thinking it would be the exact same. Ohhh nooo it wasn’t. This years batch is verrrryyyy tight, sheer in unflattering places, and most definitely runs smaller than usual. The sizing chart is off and the quality of the fabric is very cheap, but I guess you get what you pay for. I was very disappointed as I was very excited to get what I thought would be my second comfy pair of leggings from AE. Please take note of this review, because I didn’t listen to the poor reviews prior to my purchase, and I regret it.

I bought these leggings last year and wore them all year. I was so excited to get some more pairs this year. These leggings are nothing like last years style. They are cheap and feel and look like the leggings you can buy at Walmart. They do not stay up either. I will definitely be returning these. AE just bring back the ones from last year and throw these away.

these are actually the worst leggings i’ve ever bought. Just save your money. Forever 21 leggings are much better quality for 1/4 of the price. leggings should not give me a muffin top. the size chart is wrong. i tried on a pair i ordered and the entire backside ripped out after never being worn. horrible quality, no stretch, not soft.

I ordered the originals last year around winter and fell in love with them. When I went to order more this year, they said the OG replaced the chill leggings so I bought four pairs thinking I'd love them. You guys, there's no support; the material is super thin in comparison to the pair I bought last year, and they don't stay up. SUPER disappointed in these. Maybe the formula will switch in the winter and thicker material will come out? Who knows, but I don't recommend these ones.

I wore these about three times and ended up with a hole in the knee. Keep in mind I wore these to lounge and was not doing any activity in them. Very disappointed. Even without the hole, these leggings were not very comfortable compared to other leggings that I own.

These leggings are awful. I bought two pairs based on the positive reviews, but you get what you pay for. They feel like they have zero stretch, run small, and the waistband doesn’t stay up. Uncomfortable and unwearable.